Can bilirubin/albumin ratio predict neurodevelopmental outcome in severe neonatal hyperbilirubinemia? A 3-month follow up study

Abstract

Background

The risk of kernicterus and BIND may be in part determined by total serum bilirubin (TSB) and by the level of non-albumin bound free bilirubin, which can easily pass the blood–brain barrier. Free bilirubin (Bf) seems a more reliable predictor for bilirubin neurotoxicity. Bilirubin/albumin ratio (B/A) is considered a surrogate parameter for Bf and has been more useful than TSB. The aim of the study is to determine whether B/A ratio correlates with BIND in newborns with severe hyperbilirubinemia and if it can predict poor neurologic outcome at 3 months follow up.

Results

This prospective study included one hundred seventeen outborn neonates ≥ 35 weeks admitted in a tertiary care neonatal intensive care unit, between May and December 2012, with TSB ≥ 20 mg/dl or necessitating exchange transfusion. Total serum bilirubin and serum albumin were done on admission and bilirubin/albumin ratio was calculated. BIND score was calculated. At the age of 3 months, 112 neonates were followed up with a detailed neurological assessment. Babies who depicted any abnormal motor examination were subjected to brain stem auditory evoked response and MRI examination. Seven infants (6.2%) presented with kernicterus on follow up. BIND scores on admission, mean TSB, and bilirubin/albumin ratio was significantly higher in kernicteric infants compared with those having normal neurological outcome at 3 months of age (P 0.001). The lowest TSB level at which kernicterus occurred in our study was 31 mg/dl. Receiver operation characteristics analysis identified B/A ratio cut off value for predicting kernicterus of 9.6 with sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 91.4%, whereas TSB cut off value of 30 mg/dl showed sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 83%.

Conclusion

B/A ratio is a strong indicator for the risk of kernicterus. B/A is more specific than TSB and should be used in the early management of neonatal hyperbilirubinemia.

Background

Approximately 60–70% of term infants develop jaundice in the first week of life [1]. Syndrome of bilirubin-induced neurologic dysfunction (BIND) represents a spectrum of neurologic manifestations among vulnerable infants who have experienced an exposure to bilirubin. Clinical neuro motor manifestations extend from a range of subtle processing disorders with objective disturbances of vision, motor power, hearing, speech, cognition, and language among infants with history of moderate to severe hyperbilirubinemia [2].

Clinical signs of acute bilirubin encephalopathy (ABE) were reported by Van Praagh [3] and Volpe [4]. Johnson et al. [5] designed bilirubin encephalopathy into a 9-point bilirubin-induced neurologic dysfunction (BIND) score assessing mental status, muscle tone, and cry patterns (Table 1). A BIND score of 0 is normal, whereas BIND scores 1–3, 4–6, and 7–9 were assigned to represent mild, moderate, and severe ABE, respectively; they also proposed that the BIND score could predict long term outcome [6].

Table 1 BIND score [5]

American Academy of Pediatrics (APP) guidelines for the management of neonatal hyperbilirubinemia are based on the assumption that total serum bilirubin (TSB) is the most important predictor for bilirubin encephalopathy [7]. The risk of kernicterus and BIND may be in part determined by TSB and also by the level of non-albumin bound free bilirubin (Bf), which can easily pass the blood–brain barrier and thus better reflects the bilirubin load distributed in the brain [8]. Compared with TSB, free bilirubin (Bf) seems a more reliable predictor for bilirubin neurotoxicity as assessed by auditory brainstem response (ABR) maturation and electroencephalography and to correlate better with kernicterus [9].

Unfortunately clinical laboratory measurements of Bf are not available. Bilirubin/albumin ratio (B/A) is considered a surrogate parameter for Bf and has been more useful than TSB alone to indicate the Bf concentration and predicts neurotoxicity [10]. It is recommended as a safe-guard to identify the rare infant at risk for neurotoxicity at low TSB because of a low serum albumin concentration. Clinical evidence comparing the relationships of TSB and B/A ratio with outcome is sparse [11].

The aim of the study is to determine whether B/A ratio correlates with BIND in newborns with severe hyperbilirubinemia and can predict poor neurologic outcome at 3 months follow up.

Methods

Patients

One hundred seventeen outborn neonates admitted to NICU, an academic tertiary care referral center, were enrolled in this prospective cohort study between May and December 2012. Enrollment criteria included infants with estimated gestational age ≥ 35 weeks; who developed jaundice in the first 7 days of life and having TSB ≥ 20 mg/dl or necessitating exchange transfusion according to recommendations of the AAP guidelines for management of neonatal jaundice [7]. Babies suffering from direct hyperbilirubinemia, perinatal asphyxia, CNS malformations, or hemodynamically unstable were excluded. The study protocol was approved by the ethical board and written informed consent was obtained from parents after NICU admission.

Apgar scores and birth weight could not be accurately documented since all babies were outborn and not attending regular post discharge follow up; admission weight was used instead.

Detailed neurological examinations focusing on signs of BIND was done by two independent researchers; at admission time, repeated after 6 h with the first follow up of serum bilirubin and again before discharge; findings were recorded on a checklist showing items of BIND score [5] (Table 1); then audited and score calculated by third researcher. Researchers performing initial and follow up neurological examination and calculating the BIND score were blinded to laboratory data and not involved in the patients’ management. BIND score of 1–3 represents mild ABE: probably reversible without sequelae; scores 4–6: moderate ABE; and scores 7–9: severe ABE; highly associated with death or kernicterus [12].

Laboratory workup

Total serum bilirubin and serum albumin were done on admission and bilirubin/albumin ratio was calculated. TSB was measured [13]. TSB was followed up after 6 h. Hemoglobin, hematocrit levels, and reticulocytic count were recorded. Blood group of mothers and babies together with direct Coomb’s test were performed.

Follow up at 3 months

One hundred twelve neonates were followed up at the age of 3 months. Five babies were lost for follow up. Babies underwent detailed neurological assessment including (a) muscle tone of trunk, upper, and lower limbs; (b)reflexes including deep tendon reflexes, primitive neonatal reflexes (Moro, suckling, and tonic neck reflexes), extrapyramidal reflexes (cremasteric and abdominal reflexes); and (c) neurodevelopmental assessment including head control, social smile, response to sound, and eye contact. Babies who depicted any abnormal motor examination were subjected to brain stem auditory evoked response (BAER) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Infants were diagnosed as having kernicterus if two of the following three are present, with one being an abnormality of muscle tone; abnormal MRI with the specific abnormality in the globus pallidus and/or the subthalamic nucleus and abnormal ABR auditory brain stem response [14].

Statistics

Numerical data are expressed as arithmetic mean ± SD and median (25th–75th). Inter-groups comparisons were done using Mann–Whitney test. Qualitative data were presented as number (percent) and compared using Chi-square (X²) test or Fisher’s exact test as appropriate. To assess the clinical potential of bilirubin/albumin ratio for outcome, normal versus kernicterus receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were plotted, and the area under curves (AUC) were calculated [15]. Sensitivity, specificity, PPV, NPV, and accuracy were evaluated at specified cutoff levels. Statistical analysis was run on SPSS for windows release 17 (SPSS Inc., Chicago III, USA). P values < 0.05 were considered statistically significant.

Results

Two hundred ninety-six neonates were admitted to NICU during a period of 3 months; of them, 117 (39.5%) neonates ≥ 35 weeks and suffering from severe hyperbilirubinemia (≥ 20 mg/dl) or necessitating exchange transfusion according to AAP guidelines were enrolled in the study. Male predominance was reported among the studied population, with male to female ratio of 1.4:1. Mean gestational age of enrolled newborns was 37.8 weeks; birth weight was not known in most babies and New Ballard score cannot be done since many enrolled newborns were first seen past 48 h of life; hence, admission weight was used as surrogate parameter for maturation. Their mean weight on admission was 2.9 kg. Mean onset of jaundice was 2.9 days of life, and mean age of NICU admission was 5.5 days old. Mean TSB and bilirubin/albumin ratio of the studied population on admission was 26.15 ± 6 mg/dl and 7.7 ± 1.9 respectively. Table 2 reveals the characteristics of the whole study population and admission TSB.

Table 2 Demographic and laboratory data of the studied population (n = 117)

Hemolysis accounted for 42% of etiologies of hyperbilirubinemia in enrolled newborns; 29.9% and 7.6% due to ABO and RH incompatibility respectively. While undiagnosed hemolytic causes represented 4.2%; may be attributed to minor group incompatibilities which are not routinely tested. Fifty-six percent of infants had no identifiable cause of jaundice.

Acute bilirubin encephalopathy (ABE) was found in 13.6% of the studied babies on admission. According to their BIND scores, twelve babies (10%) had subtle ABE; 3 newborns (2.5%) had moderate ABE while only one patient (0.8%) had advanced ABE.

Patients were managed according to our unit protocol based on the recommendations of the AAP for the management of severe neonatal jaundice [7]. All patients were treated with phototherapy; 18 (15.4%) neonates had exchange transfusion including all patients admitted with ABE (bind scores 2–9).

Neurologic outcome at 3 months

One hundred twelve infants returned for follow up at 3 months of age and underwent neurological assessment; 5 infants missed follow up. Seven infants (6.2%) presented with kernicterus on follow up. All 7 babies did not have head support and had hypertonia; six could not respond to sound and three had choreoathetosis. Four of the seven developed social smile and four had eye contact. MRI and BAER were done for all babies with abnormal motor examination; all MRI came normal and none showed globus pallidus affection. Six infants had severe to profound auditory impairment detected in their BAER. One kernicteric patient died at age of 5 months; cause of death is unknown.

The kernicteric group showed male predominance (57%). Of the seven kernicteric patients, one had RH incompatibility, two had ABO hemolytic disease, and 4 suffered from non-hemolytic jaundice. All kernicteric babies received intensive phototherapy and all had exchange transfusions.

Regarding BIND scores on admission of the kernicteric babies, one had advanced ABE (BIND score 7), 3 had moderate ABE (BIND score of 4, 5, and 6), while the remaining 3 patients had mild ABE (BIND score 1, 2, and 3). One of them had moderate ABE (BIND score 4) and 6 had mild ABE (BIND score 1–3) on discharge. All infants with zero BIND scores on admission were normal on follow up. All babies with BIND score ≥ 4 had neurological sequelae at 3 months of age. BIND scores on admission were significantly higher in kernicteric infants compared to infants with normal neurological outcome at 3 months of age (P 0.001) (Table 3).

Table 3 BIND score, serum bilirubin, and bilirubin albumin ratio

Newborns with normal BIND score on admission had significantly lower bilirubin albumin ratio (7.5 ± 1.7) than newborn with severe ABE (BIND 4–7) (11.8 ± 1.3) (P 0.000).

Ten (41.6%) of 24 infants with TSB ≥ 30 mg/dl showed ABE; three resolved with treatment, while 7 (29%) developed kernicterus. The lowest TSB level at which kernicterus occurred in our study was 31 mg/dl. Although five neonates with TSB < 30 mg/dl developed subtle ABE (BIND SCORE 0–1), none of them developed permanent neurological sequelae and all were normal at the time of follow up. TSB and B/A ratio on admission were significantly higher in all kernicteric patients compared to other jaundiced babies with normal neurologic outcome on follow up (P 0.001) (Table 4).

Table 4 Comparison of poor neurologic outcome, TSB, B/A ratio, and BIND scores on admission

Receiver operation characteristics (ROC) analysis identified B/A ratio cutoff value for predicting kernicterus of 9.6 (AUC 0.977) with sensitivity of 100%, specificity of 91.4%, and accuracy of 92% (Fig. 1, Table 5), whereas TSB cutoff value of 30 mg/dl showed sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 83%.

Fig. 1

ROC curve for B/A ratio. The ROC curve shows that a B/A ratio of 9.6 was 100% sensitive and 91.4% specific and 92% accurate to detect poor neurologic outcome in neonates suffering from severe neonatal hyperbilirubinemia at 3 months of age

Table 5 Sensitivity and specificity for cut offs predicting poor neurological outcome

Discussion

In this prospective observational trial, we found that BIND scores on admission, TSB, and B/A ratio were significantly higher in kernicteric infants compared to other jaundiced infants with normal neurological outcome at 3 months of age. A B/A ratio of 9.6 had sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 91% for predicting poor neurologic outcome at 3 months of age. B/A ratio was more specific than TSB in the prediction of poor neurologic outcome.

Regardless of the cause for jaundice, there is a risk of neonatal bilirubin neurotoxic sequelae that ranges from irreversible permanent injury to subtle multisensory and learning impairments during infancy. Confounding effects of prematurity, hemolysis, altered bilirubin-albumin binding, severity of bilirubin exposure, and the individual vulnerability of the infant contribute to the spectrum of clinical manifestations to be designated as syndrome of BIND [2].

Jaundice due to hemolysis is usually severe and appears within the first 24 h. Sgro et al. considered presentation within the first 48 h of age a strong predictor of abnormal neurological outcome in infants with severe neonatal hyperbilirubinemia [16]. On the contrary, we did not find any significant difference between ages of onset of jaundice among kernicteric infants compared with those having normal neurologic outcome.

In the current study, we reported ABE in 13% of our studied population. Nearly all infants who had residual neurologic deficits at 3 months follow up had BIND scores ≥ 4 on admission. Although babies with BIND score 0–1 should be completely normal at follow up [2], in the present study all but one baby were normal. This specific case had a BIND score of 1 on admission and a BIND score of 2 on discharge and had persistent neurologic affection on the 3 month follow up. He was diagnosed as Rh incompatibility, had serum bilirubin level of 41 mg/dl, and had the highest B/A (13.6) ratio among the kernicteric patients. Gamaleldin et a [17]. reported 40% of their cases suffered from ABE on admission; higher percentage than our results. This higher incidence of ABE could be explained by their inclusion criteria which required a higher admission TSB (> 25 mg/dl).

The lowest TSB level at which kernicterus occurred in our study was 31 mg/dl. Consistent with our results, Iskander et al. [11] reported that asymptomatic term newborns without risk factors rarely develop kernicterus or auditory neuropathy at TSB < 31 mg% and/or B/A < 8.6 mg/g and recommended that given the risks of exchange transfusion [18] and intensive phototherapy and close monitoring may be a safer treatment option for those infants. Mukhopadhyay et al. [19] found that all kernicteric babies in their study had TSB > 30 mg/dl as well. Analysis of this cumulative evidence may be used to revise the guidelines as to whether the cut off level at which exchange transfusion should be performed can be higher than 25 mg/dl among healthy full term neonates.

Johnson et al. [6] suggested that any infant with TSB > 35 mg/dl had post icteric sequelae regardless of age and intervention. However in the present study, 9 babies had TSB > 35 mg/dl of whom 6 patients (66.6%) had kernicterus and three appeared normal at 3 months follow up. Shapiro [14] reported that subtle neurotoxicity may appear later or even at school age as learning disabilities. This could be the case with these three newborns making long term follow up a necessity. It is clear from the previous results that there exists a wide variation in the individual response to TSB which indicates that though serum bilirubin is sensitive yet it is not specific. This also indicates that the pathogenesis of BE involves critical plasma and/or host defense variables that have to be identified.

Oh et al. [20] found that higher Bf levels are associated with a higher risk of death or adverse neurodevelopmental outcome regardless of clinical status. In the absence of an available assay for Bf, the bilirubin/albumin ratio (B/A) might provide a better estimate of Bf because it contains two of the three factors determining Bf: TSB, albumin, and the albumin-binding affinity [21]. However, due to the presence of drugs that interfere with bilirubin binding to albumin, and variations in the intrinsic affinity of albumin binding to bilirubin, Bf may be much higher than suggested by the calculated B/A ratio [22].

Considering the occurrence of bilirubin encephalopathy in preterm infants with low TSB levels, the risk of developing bilirubin neurotoxicity is not determined by TSB alone [23]. Only free bilirubin and perhaps the B/A ratio are more closely associated with BIND. Authors conclude that the pathophysiological role of low serum albumin levels must be considered in BIND especially when acidosis and jaundice are present in preterm infants [24]. Severe hemolytic disease and capillary leak from a variety of conditions can result in plasma albumin depletion. In such infants, the risk for kernicterus may occur at TSB levels well below AAP-recommended intervention levels for sick infants, but the B/A cutoff would be breeched [25].

Several experts in the field of bilirubin research advocate the additional use of B/A ratio in jaundiced infants especially when TSB level is close to that at which exchange transfusion is recommended; that is next to but not instead of TSB, on which to base the management of hyperbilirubinemia [26, 27].

Ardakani et al. [28] reported a mean B/A ratio of 10 ± 1.6 among his studied neonates presenting with BE. He identified B/A of 8 to predict acute BIND (AUC 0.957) with sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 66%, whereas a TSB cut off value of 25 mg/dl showed sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 57%; hence, agreeing with our results that B/A ratio was more specific than TSB in the prediction of poor neurologic outcome.

In their randomized controlled study, Hulzbos et al. [10] concluded that they did not find any significant effect of the additional use of B/A ratio compared to TSB-based treatment on the motor development in preterm babies at 2 years of life; however, they reported significantly higher B/A ratios in their non survivors. They speculated that the additional use of B/A ratio is a valuable parameter in the management of hyperbilirubinemia in preterm infants when the bilirubin is more harmful and the infant brain is more vulnerable to bilirubin neurotoxicity.

In their cohort of 193 term infants, Iskander et al. [11] reported that moderate to severe bilirubin encephalopathy occurred only when the molar concentration of bilirubin approached or surpassed the concentration of albumin at B/A ratio of 8.8 mg/dl. As TSB exceeds this binding capacity, free bilirubin increases dramatically and the final deposition is governed by the availability of alternative plasma binding loci and ultimately by the low solubility of free bilirubin. In the present study, all babies with B/A ratio > 13 mg/g developed kernicterus. However, we observed one baby with normal outcome at B/A ratio of 12.7 mg/g. This suggests that additional bilirubin binding sites other than albumin must exist in plasma. They partly agreed with our results that B/A ratio at cut off 11.5 is a strong predictor for residual bilirubin neurotoxicity with 100% sensitivity but they stated that B/A offers no additional advantage over TSB alone.

Despite the fact that no definite cut off value at which TSB or B/A ratio are neurotoxic is yet known, we therefore agree with Johnson and Bhutani [2] that it is very important to study and identify the individual variations in the ability to buffer bilirubin the brain and the factors that expedite or delay its neuronal exit which may render the baby more prone to neurological insults thus preventing kernicterus.

ElTatawy and colleagues [29] confirmed that a cut off TSB ≥ 27.5 mg/dl was found to detect kernicterus and auditory impairment at 1 year of age (100% sensitive, 76% specific). They found that poor neurodevelopmental outcome as well as auditory impairment was positively correlated to high TSB, high BIND score, and longer duration of exposure to severe hyperbilirubinemia. They reported that 41% of the studied population had unfavorable outcomes at 3 months of age and further reduced to 13.6% at 1 year of age since most of them improved with time. These numbers were much higher than our results in which only 6% of enrolled neonates presented with kernicterus at 3 months follow up. We attributed this difference to different methods of neurological evaluation at follow up visits.

Limitations of this study include absence of risk stratification, gestational age, and cause of jaundice was not clear in some included neonates. Serial BIND score assessment and serial measurement of TSB and albumin could not be done. Sometimes, there was some delay in performing exchange transfusion because of unavailability of needed blood group. Subtle neurological deficits could have been missed; MRI and auditory brain stem response were done only to babies having abnormal motor examination; they should have been done to all babies attending the 3 months follow up visits. Long-term follow up is needed since some neurological insults may present in school age. Further randomized controlled trials are needed to emphasize know on evidence basis whether the concurrent use of B/A ratio with TSB in the management of hyperbilirubinemia is of value or not needed.

Conclusion

B/A ratio is a strong indicator for the risk of kernicterus. B/A is more specific than TSB and should be used in the early management of neonatal hyperbilirubinemia.